Thursday, 28 February 2013

Challenges of the Judicial System and Recommended Reforms (Supervised by Dr. Zakayo Lukumay UDSM)


Prepared by:
Aloys R Rugazia (Solicitor)
Bahati Ndesarua (SPRM)
Tarsila Kisoka (RM)
Kilala Timothy (RM)
Mwakalinga Esther (RM)
Kaluyenda Janeth (RM)

A.
Challenges of the Judiciary in Tanzania

Judicial Delays
William Ewart Gladstone[1]did note a celebrated catchphrase that underpins in whole the licentiousness of delaying justice he asserts:
            “Justice delayed is justice denied”
This maxim has been coined in the world of law to the effect that if legal redress is available for a party that has suffered some injury, but is not forthcoming in a timely way, it is effectively the same as having no redress at all.  This assertion is adjoined with the Tanzania Judiciary vision which is ‘timely justice for all’.
Studies have tended to impress that the judicial delays are in most cases attributable to Judges and Magistrates who lacks considerable diligence in performing their duties.  It has been however opined that judicial diligence should not be looked upon in isolation with other factors has infrastructural resources and the inefficacy of the administration of Justice whole system[2].
Others factors contributing to judicial delays includes but not limited to; legal technicalities and formalities, prosecution delays, bulkiness of cases that are not proportion to the judicial official in place and lack of strong ADR system.
In so far as judicial diligence is concerned the Bangalore Draft Code of Judicial Conduct 2001 at paragraph 6.5 requires Judges/Magistrates to perform all judicial duties, including the delivery of reserved decision, efficiently, fairly and with reasonable promptness, Countries as Uganda has devised code of conducts to this effect, Rule 8 of the Uganda Code of Conduct for Judicial Officer which is para materie to Rule 2A(5) of the Nigerian Code of Conduct of Judicial Officers and Cannon 3 of the Code of Ethics of East Caribbean Supreme Court Judges state as follows:

“Judge or Magistrate should dispose promptly of the business of the   court.  However in so doing he must ensure that Justice is not only sure, but just.  Protracted trial of a case must be avoided whenever possible.  Where a judgment is reserved to be delivered on notice it should be delivered in next 60 days unless for good reason this is not possible”
Generally speaking if nothing is done to mend court delays then the result is obvious.  People will not view the court as an effective panacea that may solve their disputes; instead likelihood to take the laws in their own hands may be vast.
Professionalism
This is another hindering factor that denies true justice.  Its scope ranges from unqualified judicial personnel to unethical and un-industrious judicial officers. This may be looked upon in term of the following;
Qualification:
Unqualified Judges and Magistrates are not likely to propound just decision in a standard required, they will shudder over the laws and end up coming out with unreasoned decisions.  The calamity does not end there only; this type of members of the bench are likely to be used in flimsy deals, which is to allow judicial interference and imperfection.  In regard to this point Justice Lameck M S Mfalila has remarked:
A highly qualified judge both in experience and intellect is more likely to be independent hence can safeguard independence of judiciary.  A truly independent judiciary must have highly experienced and intellectually able judges apart of course from their personal integrity.  Therefore selection and appointment of Judges for a truly independent Judiciary must be based on no other consideration than merit, qualification and integrity.[3]
Ethics:
Ethics is part and parcel of professionalism, the later means the conduct and qualities that characterize or mark a profession or a professional person.  Administrators of justice are very vital and key professionals in any society who hold up a role which is the heart of the society, they may bring about or ruin peace and social order, they may create a state of unjustness or discrete it.  It is expected from them to perform their duty with high esteem and integrity.  If they allow themselves to be lured in dirty business by valuables then that is the cost of which they would have betrayed the society.  Courts will be shunned, crimes will multiply and mob justice will take the place of the legal courts.
Corruption
Rushwa ni Adui wa Haki a Swahili trite adage that ‘bribery is an enemy of justice’. Corruption is squarely outspoken as the worst enemy of Justice almost everywhere in the world, Tanzania being not an exception rather one of those corruption belt.  Through corruption justice is vended as commodity, it may be vended or purchased in an open market.  Corruption as affected the judiciary in two folds as here-down:
(1) Real Corruption; this implies a situation where administrators of justice are given money or valuables in contemplation or as a consideration for deciding a case in favour of a person who has offered bribe.

(2) Perceived Corruption: The judiciary having been taken too deeply onto the tradition of receiving bribes it has gained undeserving reputation from the society that it is always corrupt, that is the society have developed a myth that there can no be justice in the court without giving something petty or significant.
In response to this Professor Athony Kronman[4], in his book The lost Lawyer: falling ideals of the Legal Profession, has pointed out momentously:
            “The legal profession now stands in danger of loosing its soul…”
These words are worth to conclude this point, indeed if nothing is done to stamp out corruption; the legal profession is apt to loose it soul, for the simple reason that no one will afford some faith to the laws and those who masters them.
Technicalities
This is another clog that has continued to nibble the judiciary for a long time.  While the laws of procedure are intended to be the handmaid of justice but they have severally been applied as to deny substantial justice. Justice Collins, R.M. correctly underscored the purpose of procedural laws in the English case of Coles and Ravensher (1907) 1 KB 1, with the following description inter alia:
“Although I agree that a court cannot conduct its business without a code of procedure, I think that the relation of the rule of practice to the work of justice is intended to be that of handmaid rather that of mistress, and the court ought not to be so far bound and tied by rules of procedure as to be compelled to do what will cause injustice to the particular case”.

In Tanzania this position finds its ground on Article 107A of the United Republic of Tanzania Constitution 1977.  Albeit, and regardless to this, technicalities continue to be a stumbling block in acquiring justice. Sometime the Court of Appeal which is the highest in the hierarchy has hidden its face behind the rules of procedure instead of facing a strenuous duty of deciding cases on their merit which would be purportedly important precedent to the lower courts, an example to illustrate this point are the cases hereunder:-
In the two cases of Nkandi Nangela V. R[5]and Philemon Chatunda V. R[6]the Justice in the Tanzania High Court of Mbeya were indifferent in regard to the requirement by the Economic and Organized Crime Control Act 1984, which provided that the accused persons charged under the Act must deposit half of the money they are alleged to squander in order to secure the bail.  In the Chatunda’s Case Justice Chua ruled out that the provision to that effect was unconstitutional whereas in Nkandi’s case Justice Mwakasendo thought that the provision was valid hence triggering an appeal.

On the appeal, the Court of Appeal instead of directing its mind towards unraveling the meritorious issue as to the constitutionality of the provision[7], it found out an escape route and simply said that technically the constitutional issue was not part of the original suit hence could not be made as point of appeal.

In the case of Cooper Motors Corporation V. Arusha international Conference Centre[8]the court of appeal struck out the appeal simply because the decree was signed by a resident magistrate who was discharging the function of an absent District Registrar.  The Resident Magistrate was signing court papers as an acting Registrar a position to which he was not formerly appointed.  Critically looking at this it was the judiciary default, the burden of which was onerously imputed to the petitioner.

In Total Tanzania Ltd V. Yahya Ahmed[9] non-service of the record of appeal within 7 days of lodging the appeal as required by the court of appeal Rules was ruled out to be fatal by the court and thus leading to the throwing out of the case in which the subject matter was Millions of cash.  Technicalities also prove to be cruel against non-lawyers who crave for justice. They find themselves flummoxed with the rules of procedures which sometime are not cognizable even to the trained lawyers. Procedures stand in their way as a predicament denying them substantial justice.

Judicial Infrastructures
Poor working environment, poor facilities, poor record management, lack of ICT and database system have also led to backlogs in judicial justice dispensation rendering the obvious problems that are attached to the a foregoing.  They are causatives to uncertainties in decision making due to poor precedent record management and also judicial delays rendering to the crude and unfriendly environment.  Henceforth Professor William Binchy has stated:

The relationship between judicial, infrastructural resources and efficiency of the system for the administration of justice is a complex one.  In any particular case of delay it may be hard to distil the precise competent that is attributable to lack of diligence on the part of the judge…..”

Language of the Court
English as used in court have been blamed to be a fettering factor to easy dispensation and access of justice.  Without further ado it suffices to turn up and Quote the C.J. hon. Mohamed Chande Othman who sums it all in the following proposition:
“With our laws predominantly in English, ‘the language of the law’ rather than Kiswahili the ‘ language of the people’ it is no surprise that it is often difficult for ordinary people in “Tanzania to press for Justice as rightly found in Tanzania….. we need to rethink and if need be, reposition Kiswahili as the prime language of Justice delivery”.

This underpins it all.  Language barrier is one of those forts that prevent people from rightfully and smoothly accessing Justice.

B
Reformation

Improving the ICT
Recording the evidence adduced manually is precarious bearing human inabilities; there is a need to have the judiciary basic reforms in the area of the application of ICT in the administration of justice.  That is improvement of database management, case filing and record keeping effectiveness, recording the evidence adduced electronically, and giving up dates on the new laws of procedure and application process in the Judiciary Web for example giving out pleading templates and court forms etc.

Rehabilitating and the infrastructures Improvement
The current situation is horrific, magistrates and judges do not find the working environment conducive.  The working tools are poor and inadequate i.e. court building, office stationeries, and office accommodations hence retarding expeditions delivery of justice.  In a deformational approach, all these areas need to be revitalized.[10]

Recruiting adequate number of judicial officers
There is also inadequate number of Judges and Magistrate hence triggering backlog of cases, consequently bulky suits preferred in court in daily basis cannot be effectively attended to given the limited number of officers in place.  There is a clarion need of recruiting more judicial officers, failure of which a fallen of unattended cases will persist to lay stagnant in the courts.

Strengthening the laws dealing with Judicial Misconduct and Corruption
There is a dire need to scheme and strength the laws in regard to judicial diligence, corruptions and misconduct, in short there is a need of premising a code of conduct whose application must be strengthened.
Combating Corruption
Strong and deliberate actions ought to be taken to do away with corruption.  There is a clarion necessity of envisaging deliberate measures to assure that the court is corruption free.  It should be distilled and borne in the mind of lawyers serving in the bench and bar just as Prof Kronman[11] had an occasion to observe and I quote:

The outstanding lawyer, as his ideal presents him, is to begin with a devoted citizen.  He cares about the public good and he is prepared to sacrifice is own well being for it, unlike those who uses the law only to advance their private ends…”
This advice need to be heeded upon to bred a corruption free Judiciary.

Recruitment based on Merits and Integrity
The recruitment of the personnel to the judiciary ought to be grounded on merits and integrity.  Bearing the seriousness and importance of the judiciary it cannot afford to have in office unqualified and unethical staff members.  Therefore recruitment on the judiciary should be based on no more than merits and self esteem.

ADR
Alternative Dispute resolution mechanism needs to be whetted and improved.  This will reduce congestion of cases in the courts.  Attached mediation introduced with Order 8A of the Civil Procedure Code[12] has also been criticized for being unrealistic because the parties are subjected to it as a matter of law and not with a strong determination by the parties themselves to call off the matter.  Therefore it ought to be expunged.

Language of the Court
The language of the court should be the language of the people which in Tanzania is Swahili.

C. Conclusion
The herein above are the challenges and areas that ought to be reformed.




[1] UK Prime Minister15 August 1892-2 March 1894
[2] Chris Peter Maina Et al ( Editors): Law and Justice in Tanzania: Quarter of a century of the Court of Appeal: (Pub MkukinaNyota 2007) at pg 207
[3]Law and Justice in Tanzania 2007 Supra pg 87
[4] The Dean Faculty:Yale Law School
[5] High Court of Tanzania at MbeyaMiscAppliction no 1 of 1991
[6] High Court of Tanzania at MbeyaMisc Economic Crime Application no. 11 of 1990
[7] Mbushuu Dominic Mnyaroje V. R (1995) TLR 97
[8] Court of Appeal Tanzania at Arusha Civil Appeal no 42 of 1997
[9] Court of Appeal of Tanzania at Arusha Civil Appeal no.41 of 1997
[10] See the Tanzania Law Reform Commission of Tanzania Report; Uploaded Flow of Criminal Justice at pg 6.
[11] Anthony A Kronman: The Lost Lawyer: failing Ideals of the Legal profession, Harvard University Press, March15,1995
[12] Cap 33( R.E 2002)

2 comments:

  1. ipo vizur but font color naona kama haiko vizuri imekolea mpaka inaumiza macho

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sands Casino | Temecula, CA - Tucson, USA
    Welcome 샌즈카지노 to Temecula's most exciting, award-winning casino resort, 바카라 사이트 located 25 minutes from หาเงินออนไลน์ downtown Temecula. Our casino offers a full gaming floor with over 2000 slot machines

    ReplyDelete